Suikoden II is an act of faith, not a trick of grammar

Suikoden is a great JRPG with lousy translation work; that said, Suikoden II is an even greater JRPG with lousier translation work. The proof is in the published work. This is the PlayStation 1 era, meaning there’s no way to patch the game and cover up caught mistakes. I did this for Suikoden after I beat it and figured I might as well snap some slanted cell phone shots of poor grammar or translating problems as I went through Suikoden II all over again. I did not expect to take so many photos. Truth be told, I grew lenient as I played, and so the following is not every bit of wonky wordsmithing I saw.

All right, let’s do this my fellow grammar geeks.

WP_20140916_001

The joke here is that the true Hodor would never say such a thing. Simply “Hodor.”

WP_20140916_002

Since, y’know, YOU ARE PRISONER.

WP_20140916_003

I immediately found it strange that, for every shop in Suikoden II, the words “buy” and “sell” are lowercased while everything else is not.

WP_20140918_002

Maybe Nanami meant an Estate spy?

WP_20140925_001

You really don’t see many people using the form Its’ these days…

WP_20141009_001

Um…what?

WP_20141120_001

At this point, not even the makers of Suikoden II can remember how to spell their main villain’s name.

WP_20141121_001

Maybe you’re too quick at writing these pre-cook off blurbs.

WP_20141123_002

Wrong. I know not that name. There is only McDohl. There can be only one.

WP_20141125_001

“This is home I make my living” sounds like something you’d want to shout angrily. THIS IS HOME, I MAKE MY LIVING!!!1!1!!!

WP_20141128_003

Remember when they got Luca Blight’s and McDohl’s names wrong? Well, let’s add Jowy to the list.

WP_20141129_001

YOU ARE EYES.

WP_20141129_002

Some time after defeating Neclord, things got weird. Any time I ran away from a fight, the game replaced Hodor’s name with one of the enemy’s names. Thus…ZombieSlug.

I’ll probably restart Suikoden III early next year. Here’s hoping the translation work got better once the series hit a new console platform. Here’s hoping.

Advertisements

4 responses to “Suikoden II is an act of faith, not a trick of grammar

  1. I enjoyed this post! I wouldn’t say I’m the biggest stickler on grammar, but I’m always quick to notice glaring inconsistencies. I suppose that comes part and parcel with being someone who enjoys writing and reading so much.

    • Thanks, Matt! I don’t think most current day games are this bad translation-wise, but I still see plenty of spelling/grammar errors in AAA titles. If only every company would hire me to freelance edit…

  2. You forgot to add “It looks like something is supposed to to be stuck into this depressed area” (sic) 😀

  3. There’s nothing wrong with the last one

    If your level is significantly higher than the monster’s level, the ‘escape’ button becomes ‘release’ which have 100% rate of success, and the text mentions that the monsters are the one who’s escaping

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s